Ranking the greatest players in NBA history inevitably sparks debate, but one of the most widely accepted assumptions—that Kareem Abdul-Jabbar belongs firmly in the top three—deserves more scrutiny. While Kareem’s longevity and counting stats are undeniably impressive, a closer look at the context of his career suggests he should be ranked closer to eighth all-time rather than among the very top tier.
View the latest NBA odds at Bovada!
The 1970s
First, Kareem’s prime came during one of the weakest decades in NBA history: the 1970s. The existence of the rival American Basketball Association drained talent from the National Basketball Association for nearly a decade. Stars like Julius Erving, George Gervin, Artis Gilmore, and Dan Issel spent significant portions of their primes outside the NBA. The result was a diluted league where the level of competition—particularly at the top—was noticeably lower than in later eras. Kareem dominated statistically in this environment, but dominance in a weakened league doesn’t carry the same historical weight.
Despite winning three MVPs in the 1970s, Kareem’s teams frequently failed to translate his individual brilliance into playoff success. After leading the Milwaukee Bucks to the title in 1971 alongside Oscar Robertson, his postseason résumé becomes much shakier. In 1972, the Bucks were eliminated in the Western Conference Finals by the Los Angeles Lakers, led by Wilt Chamberlain. In that series, Chamberlain arguably outplayed Kareem in the decisive moments, particularly defensively, as the Lakers won in six games on their way to a historic championship season.
The pattern continued throughout the decade. In the 1974 Finals against the Boston Celtics, Kareem had big numbers (32.6 points per game), but the series still exposed limitations. Dave Cowens, an undersized center compared to Kareem, held his own physically and helped push Boston to a seven-game victory. Kareem’s famous Game 6 skyhook forced a Game 7, but the Bucks ultimately fell short.
His early years with the Lakers were even more disappointing. After arriving in Los Angeles in 1975, Kareem won MVP in both 1976 and 1977—but his teams missed the playoffs entirely in 1976 and were eliminated in the first round in 1977 by the Golden State Warriors. For a supposed top-three player ever, missing the playoffs in your prime—even while winning MVP—raises serious questions about impact.
The Magic Johnson Era
Even when Kareem finally returned to championship contention in the 1980s, it coincided with the arrival of Magic Johnson, who fundamentally transformed the Lakers’ offense. In the famous Game 6 of the 1980 NBA Finals, Magic—not Kareem—delivered one of the most iconic performances in league history, scoring 42 points while starting at center in Kareem’s absence. It was a symbolic moment: the Lakers’ dynasty was clearly driven by Magic’s playmaking engine.
Kareem’s supporters often point to his six MVP awards and all-time scoring record as proof of his greatness. But MVP voting in the 1970s was notoriously inconsistent, and several of Kareem’s awards came during years when his teams were far from dominant. Longevity stats also benefit players who maintain productivity deep into their careers, which Kareem certainly did—but greatness at the very top of the all-time rankings typically hinges on peak dominance and postseason control.
When weighing the full picture—the diluted 1970s competition, repeated playoff disappointments in his prime, and the fact that his later championships came as part of Magic Johnson’s Lakers—Kareem’s legacy looks slightly less untouchable than commonly portrayed. He remains an all-time great without question, but placing him around eighth all-time rather than in the top three is a far more defensible position once the context of his career is fully considered.
Explore more from Drew. Click here for his opinion on the ‘Dwyane Wade vs. Kevin Durant.’
Any tips, predictions, or strategies published are entirely the opinion of the author and are not guaranteed to be correct or result in financial gain. The Author is not an employee of Bovada.
Please be aware that there are always financial risks involved in gambling and it is the responsibility of the individual to place bets with or without the information provided on this website. Bovada cannot be held responsible for any financial losses that may be incurred as a result of following any of the tips, predictions, or strategies provided on this website.