Every NBA fan has wondered the same question: if the league’s best players went head-to-head in a true one-on-one tournament, who would actually come out on top?
Imagine an All-Star Weekend event built around pure isolation basketball. The format would include three height divisions — 6’4 and under, 6’5 to 6’9, and 6’10 and above — with a three-dribble limit and a 10-second shot clock to keep things moving. It would showcase skill, footwork, and shot-making in its purest form. In a weekend that’s been searching for fresh energy, a 1v1 tournament might be exactly what the NBA needs to save All-Star Weekend – so let’s all hope Suns owner Matt Ishbia is telling the truth when he says he wants to do it next year and give $1M to the winner.
6’4 and Under Division: Ant over Harden
In the guards division, the edge goes to Anthony Edwards over James Harden, and it comes down to explosiveness and defensive versatility. Harden’s résumé is legendary—over 25,000 career points, a scoring title streak, and a peak season averaging 36.1 points in 2018–19. But so much of Harden’s dominance at this point in his career comes from manipulating team defenses, drawing fouls, and orchestrating pick-and-rolls. In a pure isolation environment with no help from defenders, that advantage shrinks dramatically – even if his strength and shifty handles are enough to get him to the championship game.
Edwards, meanwhile, is built for exactly this format. At roughly 225 pounds with elite burst and a near 40-inch vertical, he’s one of the most physically overwhelming guards in the league. He’s already a 25+ point-per-game scorer and shoots around 40% from three, forcing defenders to respect every level. The real separator, though, is defense. Edwards can lock up opposing players, and in one-on-one basketball, the player who can both score and stop the other wins possessions—and Edwards checks both boxes.
6’5 to 6’9 Division: Tatum over LeBron
Picking Jayson Tatum over LeBron James sounds blasphemous historically, but in a current one-on-one tournament, the case is stronger than people think. LeBron’s career numbers are untouchable—over 40,000 points, elite playmaking, and four MVPs. He’d be able to overpower opposing wings both off the dribble and in the post, while also getting to his jumper, and a locked-in LeBron can still shut you down defensively, but the run would end with Tatum.
Because Tatum is almost tailor-made for isolation scoring. At 6’8” with a long wingspan, he combines elite shot-creation with modern perimeter skills. Now healthy again, he’s a 30-point-per-game scorer in his prime years while taking and making difficult step-back threes and mid-range jumpers. His scoring versatility is enormous: post-ups, pull-ups, drives, and off-the-dribble threes.
Defensively, Tatum is also an elite wing stopper who regularly guards the opponent’s best player. While LeBron still possesses incredible strength, the reality is age—Tatum’s youth, conditioning, and scoring rhythm would likely overwhelm even the all-time great. In a pure scoring duel today, Tatum’s shot-making arsenal gives him the edge.
6’10 and Above Division: KD over Embiid
When the giants face off, Kevin Durant becomes the ultimate one-on-one cheat code. Durant is essentially a 7-footer with guard skills, and that combination has produced one of the most unstoppable scoring profiles in basketball history. He’s a four-time scoring champion who averages around 27 points per game for his career while shooting roughly 50/40/90 efficiency splits at his peak. In isolation, his high-release jumper is nearly impossible to contest.
Joel Embiid is dominant in his own right. The MVP center regularly averages over 30 points per game and punishes defenders in the post with elite strength and footwork. In a half-court team game, Embiid’s physicality is overwhelming. But one-on-one introduces spacing and mobility issues.
Durant can pull Embiid away from the basket and attack off the dribble, using his length and handle to create clean jumpers. Meanwhile, Embiid would have to chase one of the greatest perimeter scorers ever. Over a series of possessions, Durant’s versatility—pull-up threes, mid-range daggers, and slashing ability—makes him the more sustainable scorer, giving him the edge in this height division.
View the latest NBA odds at Bovada!